The key to restoring West Coast salmon runs lies in ensuring there is a wide diversity of stocks within a given species, say the authors of a landmark study of sockeye in Bristol Bay, Alaska.
While big salmon rivers such as the Fraser and Skeena in British Columbia
, and the Columbia, which flows from B.C. to Oregon, have wild swings in productivity, the Bristol Bay area has remained remarkably stable, yielding average runs of 30 million fish annually since 1950.
Because of stock collapses last year, salmon fishing was widely closed throughout B.C., Washington, Oregon and California. On the Fraser, for example, all fishing was banned after an anticipated run of more than 10-million sockeye fell to around 1-million, leading to the calling of a federal commission of inquiry.
Bristol Bay, however, had another good year with the commercial fleet hauling in a catch worth US$120-million.
“Bristol Bay is a well known example of a sustainable fishery, where sockeye salmon have been caught in huge numbers reliably, year after year, since the first canneries were built in the late 1800s,” said Dr. Daniel Schindler, lead author of the study which appears Thursday on the cover of the science journal, Nature.
“In the last 50 years this fishery has produced more than $5-billion [worth] of salmon, making it one of the single most valuable fisheries in North America. Our study helps explain why the Bristol Bay sockeye fishery has been so reliable for so long,” he said in an interview from a field camp in Aleknagik, southwest Alaska.
Dr. Schindler and his co-author, Dr. Ray Hilborn, both of the University ofWashington
School of Fishery Sciences, said Bristol Bay is steadily productive because there are so many different types of sockeye there.
He said having many different populations of salmon is like having a diversified stock portfolio, in which strong performers compensate for weak ones, smoothing out the bumps.
“Our study shows that the ‘portfolio effect’ is caused by small differences in how different populations of sockeye salmon respond to their environment. Some populations perform better in cold, wet years while others thrive while it’s hot or dry,” said Dr. Schindler.
“The net result is that each population experiences its own ups and downs based on environmental conditions and pure chance. But given sufficient diversity there are enough winners to make up for the losers every year across the rivers that produce salmon in Bristol Bay,” he said.
The concept that diverse ecosystems are more stable has long been accepted in science, but the Alaska study is unique because it looks at diversity within a single species.
While sockeye are classified as one species, there can be many different sockeye populations, or stocks, in any given river, each with physical or behavioral differences shaped by the environmental.
Dr. Schindler said when stocks become homogenized – as they do when hatcheries produce huge numbers of fish or development destroys a range of habitat – the result can be boom or bust cycles.
“We estimate that without the current diversity . . . the Bristol Bay fishery would close about ten times more frequently,” said Dr. Schindler.
“We believe this new evidence from our Bristol Bay salmon study is a game changer for managing species and entire ecosystems, because the lessons from this paper result in specific advice for natural resource management,” said Dr. Hilborn.
He said salmon should be managed to promote diversity, and that means protecting a wide range of habitat, avoiding a dependence on hatcheries, and keeping catches low enough that a wide variety of stocks is allowed to return to spawn.
Dr. Hilborn said there has been a recent shift in both Canada and the U.S. towards just that type of approach.
In B.C., for example, the federal Department of Fisheries and Oceans in 2008 adopted a wild salmon policy that stresses protecting diversity. That policy is in the process of being implemented.
“In some sense this [research] is supporting evidence for the direction that many agencies are currently going,” said Dr. Hilborn.